Does it sound like Mr. S. could be a potential suspect in Hae's murder or just a creepy guy peeing in the woods? Explain your answer. How does the presentation of all of this untested evidence affect your ideas about who the killer is? Why wasn't it tested? If you were Adnan how would you feel about this?
Respond with one paragraph (8-10) sentences and comment on at least two other posts by Tuesday, 10/22@ 11:59 PM
Respond with one paragraph (8-10) sentences and comment on at least two other posts by Tuesday, 10/22@ 11:59 PM
I think that Mr. S is most definitely a suspect because he found Hae in the woods after the police couldn’t. Aside from that, people state that he had to be really looking for her to find her, considering the fact that she was buried under so much mud and was behind a fallen tree. It seems to me like it wasn’t just a coincidence that he had to pull over when his house and job were only a few miles away. Couldn’t he wait? I also find it weird that they would still blame Adnan when the school was nowhere near the park and he claims to have never heard of it nor been there. What also caught my eye was that they found a liquor bottle and Mr. S claims to have been drinking a whiskey bottle.
ReplyDeletei didnt even catch the whiskey / liquor bottle but now that you mention that i guess it does make him look bad because who knows what he couldve done while drinking.
DeleteIn my opinion Mr. S could become one of the main suspects in Hae Lee’s crime because all the time he was saying that he found the body in Leakin Park. He said that he was peeing in the woods when he found the body. My point of view is based on Mr. S being one of the main suspects, because he was the first one who got to see the body before the police, he also admitted that he was drinking whiskey, and coincidentally there was a bottle of liquor found close to the body. If i was Adnan, I’d try to do my best to make the police do a deeper investigation on Mr. S. The park was not even close to the school. What was she doing there, or why would there be a creepy guy in the woods drinking liquor if his house and his job are close.
ReplyDeletei agree with adnan attempting to have the police investigate it more - they should've in the first place because its either a hit or miss but you wont lose anything by running a few tests just to be sure.
DeleteMr. S could be a possible suspect to all this but I don't think he killed her. If the body was really that hard to spot then maybe he buried it and it had been a little while since then that he decided to report it. No it doesnt change my perspective / ideas on who the killer is because personally this feels off. It probably wasn't tested because he was the one to report it and not much was thought about it since what he had been convicted of has nothing to do with being a murderer in the first place. If i were adnan id feel sick IF he was the one who buried it and knew all this time however if he didnt then i’d still feel bothered and uneasy for not knowing who did it.
ReplyDeleteI am not sure as whether or not Mr. S did it because while the body was impossible to spot unless you looked, a bottle of liquor was found right next to the body after Mr. S admitted he was drinking at that time and had a police record for indecent exposure, he did not fail his polygraph test the second time and fully cooperated with police.
ReplyDeleteI don't think Mr. S commited the crime because our narrator said that after speaking to many people she didn't find any connections between Hae and Mr. S or to Adnan. So there is no reason why he would kill Hae. But the whole situation and how he describes how he found her. It doesn't seem right. The fact that other people missed her body because it blended with everything in that setting and he didn't, he saw what everyone else didn't. So i wonder what is it that it's not making his story sound right. How could he have stopped exactly where Hae's body was laying , that he felt the need to urinate and stopped right where Hae's body was. There is something that he might not be telling us and that could help determine if Adnan did it or not. Mr. S also has a record and even though the things he does it's not violent it still makes him suspicious in the eyes of the cops. He could just be a creepy guy doing creepy things if he didn't find Hae's body so easily but the problem is that Hae's body was well hidden and he was the only one that saw what everyone else.
ReplyDelete